Solar farm debate hears that land could be compulsorily purchased - and more

By Robert Alexander - Local Democracy Reporting Service

4th Oct 2023 | Local News

Controversial plans to build a solar farm on land in Rutland and Stamford, Lincs, are being discussed by the Planning Inspectorate. Image credit: LDRS.
Controversial plans to build a solar farm on land in Rutland and Stamford, Lincs, are being discussed by the Planning Inspectorate. Image credit: LDRS.

The Mallard Pass Planning Inspectorate hearing has been taking place, with more discussion to continue surrounding controversial solar farm proposal.

Those in attendance heard that land could be compulsorily purchased to make way for a solar farm - and more.

Public hearings into the controversial plans for the Mallard Pass Solar Farm, which would straddle the Lincolnshire and Rutland border, continued last week before David Cliff, the examining inspector appointed by the secretary of state.

If approved, Mallard Pass, would take up a site measuring 906 hectares, with solar panels on 463 hectares, and would be the UK's largest solar farm. Covering a site of over 2,000 acres across 52 separate fields, it would be 10 times bigger than the largest existing solar plant in the country.

Because of the scale, it will be decided by the Planning Inspectorate rather than the local authorities.

Last week's hearings, held at Orton Hall Hotel in Peterborough, were the last where members of the public, interested parties, campaigners and the developer could put their case forward face-to-face.

On Tuesday, the examiner heard arguments for and against the compulsory land acquisitions and temporary possessions that are expected to happen if the project is approved.

The application is subject to rules that require government departments to look at whether surplus land would eventually be offered back to the former owner at the current market value, after the government has finished using it.

However, this led to a heated exchange over the 'lifespan' of the project which had originally been proposed at 40 years, but has subsequently been extended to 60 years.

Members of the Mallard Pass Action Group pointed out that the solar panels have, at best, a lifespan of between 25 and 30 years, after which they become less efficient.

For a project of 60 years, this would mean all 530,000 solar panels having to be removed and replaced at least once during the lifespan of the development.

It was also pointed out to the examiner that worldwide resources for crystalline silicon, the primary material in a solar cell, are rapidly diminishing, and that there may not be enough of the material left in 40 or 50 years' time to make all the panels requiring refurbishment or replacing.

The solar panels will be 3.3 metres in height. Image credit: MP Alicia Kearns.

Arguments both for and against the effects the development will have on biodiversity and the environment were heard, as well concerns over the archaeology that may be discovered, disturbed, or possibly destroyed.

The enquiry heard that all large projects like this must take into account what are known as biodiversity net gain (BNG) decisions: a way of contributing to the recovery of nature while developing land, to make sure the habitat for wildlife is in a better state than it was before development.

BNG, which is measured as a positive or negative percentage, reflects the good or harm the development will have on the land

The Mallard Pass Action Group pointed out to the examiner that the application, if approved in its current form, would result in a -45 BNG score for the project overall, and a -29 BNG score in hedgerows lost alone.

Noise pollution and road disruption were also raised as concerns with an estimated 15,000 40ft containers needed just to transport the panels to the site.

The examiner also heard about the issues homeowners could face, including as 'glint and glare' from the panels, privacy worries over the CCTV, and the miles of 2m-high fencing surrounding the farm.

Further sessions this month and next will take place behind closed doors with only the interested parties attending.

Rutland's Conservative MP, Alicia Kearns (Con), who opposes the project, has this week demonstrated the height of the solar panels in locations around the county.

Alicia Kearns said: "This is the reality of the height of the panels, the same panels the companies applying to build them say wouldn't prevent us enjoying the 'permissive footpaths' they may include."

Ms Kearns has also recently been out in Rutland and Stamford demonstrating the height of the 3.3m proposal panels, comparing them to the height of local landmarks to offer perspective.

     

New stamford Jobs Section Launched!!
Vacancies updated hourly!!
Click here: stamford jobs

Share:

Related Articles

Cocktail of the Week: Island Breeze. Image credit: Josh Tooley
Local Features

Cocktail of the Week: Island Breeze

Outside seating in the Coffee Room. Image credit: Easton Walled Gardens.
Local News

New Stationery and Book Shop opening at Easton Walled Gardens

Sign-Up for our FREE Newsletter

We want to provide stamford with more and more clickbait-free local news.
To do that, we need a loyal newsletter following.
Help us survive and sign up to our FREE weekly newsletter.

Already subscribed? Thank you. Just press X or click here.
We won't pass your details on to anyone else.
By clicking the Subscribe button you agree to our Privacy Policy.